Steam's AI Problem Is Low Effort, Not AI

Published .

The Valve wordmark in fiery orange facing the Steam logo in electric blue, with sparks clashing between them

Valve is right not to police which tools developers use. The problem on Steam is low effort, and AI just makes low effort faster and cheaper.

This week in Busan, developers asked Valve about AI slop and AI clones, and the answers were more candid than we expected. Below we cover what Valve said, why we think it’s right, and how indie devs can protect a game from AI clones.

What Valve said

At Steam Indie Connect on October 27, Valve’s Tom Giardino and Marc Wilkinson took questions from Korean developers. The line everyone quoted came from Giardino. “We don’t want to be gatekeepers telling developers which tools they should or shouldn’t use.”

He also said clones were a problem long before AI. People have always spotted a fun idea at Next Fest and rushed out something similar. AI has simply sped that up.

Wilkinson was just as direct about the slop. “We are fully aware of the situation,” he said, and a significant number of people at Valve are thinking about how to solve it. That’s not a fix, but it’s an honest admission.

The extortion emails

The most unsettling part came from one developer’s question. Indie studios have been getting emails that say, in effect, pay up or we’ll clone your game with AI and release it first. It’s an egregious tactic, and it lands on the people least able to absorb it.

Giardino said it was the first he’d heard of these cases. He called extortion more of a matter for law enforcement than for a store, but added that if developers report it, Valve wants to look into it and help.

Why the shelf feels so crowded

Steam has seen nearly 23,000 releases in 2026 so far, and it isn’t even November. The latest Next Fest hosted over 8,000 demos.

Wilkinson explained why the festival can feel like a deluge. For the first two days, games are shown to players virtually at random, and only then do personalized recommendations kick in. The random start gives every game a fair shot, and Valve admits the trade-off is that some low-quality games get exposed.

So a lot of the “Next Fest is all slop” posts come from those first two days. With 8,000 demos in the mix, that’s an inexorable result of fairness, not proof that the whole event has drowned.

AI is part of the picture, but not all of it. Roughly 17% of the previous year’s Next Fest demos disclosed generative AI use. That’s a real share, and it still leaves most of the crowd made the old-fashioned way.

Why we think Valve has this right

Banning a tool sounds tidy. In practice, it would be a quixotic job. AI now shows up in code helpers, texture tools, voice, translation and testing, and lots of careful developers use it well.

A tool ban would also miss the target. A rushed clone made by hand is still a rushed clone. What players dislike is the copy-paste mindset, and that existed long before any model could write a line of code.

Valve’s own history points the same way. Valve treats clones like it treats piracy. Instead of heavy DRM, it focuses on making the legitimate version the best version. It also turned down similar requests to filter out Greenlight and Steam Direct games in years past.

The criticism is fair, though. Valve’s approach puts the onus on developers to protect themselves. That’s a real cost, and a store with Valve’s reach can keep improving discovery so the original wins more often.

What AI can’t copy

AI makes a mechanic cheap to copy. It can’t copy a Discord full of people who care, a steady run of updates, or the odd specific taste that made the game feel like yours.

That was Giardino’s point. “Rather than relying on a single mechanic that someone can easily copy, you need to keep growing your game by adding features, personality, and creativity that stem from your own perspective,” he said.

A clone is a facsimile of one moment in your game’s life. If the game keeps moving, the copy goes stale fast.

It isn’t only Steam

The same pattern turned up on Roblox this week. There’s been a wave of reportedly AI-assisted ports copying games like Elden Ring, Counter-Strike and Sonic Generations, with ripped assets and near-identical menus. Many have since been taken down.

A recreation of the PS4 dashboard logged more than 178,700 visits before its listing changed to “Content Deleted.”

How to protect your game from AI clones

Build a community early. Valve called community the first line of defense, and also said it takes time and won’t happen automatically. Start a Discord, post devlogs, and let players see the people behind the game before you launch.

Keep shipping updates. A clone copies the version it saw. Regular patches, new content and visible changelogs keep the original ahead and give players a reason to stay.

Show your work anyway. Demos and Next Fest still matter for discovery. Being public early also makes it obvious who made the game first if a copy shows up.

Report clones and threats. If someone threatens to clone your game for money, report it to Valve and to your local police. Keep the emails, dates and any store links. Valve said it wants to hear about these cases.

Know the rules for your own AI use. If you use AI tools yourself, check what you own and what Steam asks you to disclose. Our guide on who owns a game made with AI covers the rules by tool and by store.

QuickMatch Weekly

New and updated AI game tools, with sources, in one short email.

One email a week. New AI game tools, price changes, and deals. Unsubscribe anytime.