One quick decision during a livestream turned into the biggest studio fight of the week. Over the Halloween weekend, a Dead by Daylight team member gave a controversial streamer every paid character and perk. Four days later the studio had apologized twice, taken the content back, and was being review-bombed on Steam by both sides. Below is what happened, told as neutrally as we can, and what any team that works with creators can take from it.
Image: Dead by Daylight, © Behaviour Interactive (official Steam screenshot).
What happened
On October 30, Twitch streamer and VTuber TheBurntPeanut was granted access to all of Dead by Daylight’s DLC characters and perks during a livestream, plus in-game currency. He had not played the game before. VGC put the value at a reported $300 or so.
Some players objected right away. The streamer has faced repeated accusations of offensive behavior, including alleged use of slurs and alleged viewbotting, and critics said the gift clashed with the game’s inclusive community. Seemingly aware of how it would look, he offered to give it back: “If you don’t want people on Twitter to be upset, I’ll take the heat and you can take away the DLC,” VGC reports.
The reply, in all caps, came from an official Dead by Daylight account (reports differ on whether it was posted in Twitch chat or the game’s Discord): “WE CAN TAKE THE HEAT! THEY ARE YOURS TO KEEP”, with a heart emoji.
Two apologies in three days
On November 1, Behaviour Interactive posted a statement on its DbD Pulse account. It said unlocking content for new creators “is not unusual,” but this time the decision “was made without receiving appropriate approvals,” and the team member’s “subsequent comments and conduct do not align with Dead by Daylight’s core values.” It added that “threatening employees will never be acceptable.”
That didn’t settle it, so on November 3 a longer, four-page statement went up on the main Dead by Daylight account. It explained that the team saw “a very large audience appear in the DbD Twitch directory watching a streamer who has not played DbD before” and “moved too fast.” Behaviour admitted it “did not have stringent enough processes and guardrails internally” to stop one person granting items without wider approval. It said the chat reply “crossed the line of appropriate responses from our brand.”
The studio confirmed it had removed the gifted content. It is rewriting its creator guidelines, “including who on our team can make those calls,” updating how content and currency get approved, and training staff. It said it is taking “appropriate action internally” but won’t share details.
Now both sides are angry
The second statement opened a new front. Some players felt the studio caved to pressure. Asmongold called it a “pathetic capitulation that will earn the respect of no one,” and Dr Disrespect also criticized Behaviour for apologizing. Others were upset that the gift happened at all, or that taking it back after “yours to keep” made the flip-flop worse.
Kotaku reports that both sides are now review-bombing the game on Steam. The 2016 release still holds a “Mostly Positive” rating, but a wave of negative reviews has dragged it down a few points. One reads “Justice for Peanut.” Another says the writer won’t spend more time or money on a company that supports the streamer.
There’s no clean winner here. Both camps are reacting to the same thing: a big decision made in seconds, in public, by one person with the brand’s voice.
What devs and community managers can learn
Write down a creator access policy before you need it. Free keys and unlocks for streamers are normal and often worth it. Decide ahead of time what you give, to whom, and what checks come first. Behaviour says it normally reviews a creator’s past content before working with them. The process existed, but nothing forced it to happen.
Limit who can grant paid content. If one account can hand out every DLC live, that’s a tooling problem, not just a judgment problem. Require a second person to approve big grants, log every one, and keep “give everything” off the menu in admin tools.
Slow down when a big audience shows up. A sudden spike of viewers is exciting, which is exactly when mistakes happen. A short rule like “no gifts or official chat posts until someone has checked the channel” would have prevented all of this.
Treat the official account as the studio speaking. An all-caps joke from a personal account is banter. From the brand, “WE CAN TAKE THE HEAT” reads as policy. Agree on tone rules for live chats and Discord, and on who steps in when a thread starts going wrong.
Know how review bombs work on Steam. Since 2019, Steam has flagged unusual bursts of review activity. If Valve decides the burst is off-topic, meaning it’s about something outside the game itself, those reviews are left out of the score by default. Players can still read them and opt back in to counting them. Off-topic reviews get flagged; reviews about the gameplay stay. Don’t fight reviewers in the comments. Fix the real problem and let the system and time work.
Write one clear apology, not two. Behaviour’s first statement was short and vague, so a second, longer one was needed, and each statement restarted the conversation. A good apology says what happened, admits the specific mistake, says what changes, and protects staff from harassment. Post it once, on the main account, and then follow through quietly.
Don’t reverse a gift casually. Taking back something you called “yours to keep” angered a new group of people. If you might have to undo a decision, don’t make it in public until you’re sure.
None of this is unique to a big studio. Any indie team that sends keys to streamers or runs a Discord can face a smaller version of the same week.
